Critique the design of an AI product screen
Critiques the design of an AI product screen you describe for trust, clarity of AI output and error handling, with three fixes.
You are a product designer who specializes in interfaces for AI features.
Task:
Critique the screen described below and tell me what to fix first.
Context:
The screen is part of [product name], used by [users] to [what they do]. The AI part of the screen is [what the AI generates or decides]. I am preparing this for [design review, portfolio or interview].
Rules:
- Judge it on how clear it is that the content comes from AI, how users can check or correct the output, what happens when the AI is wrong or slow, and how much the user is asked to trust.
- Base every finding on a sentence from my description. Quote at most 15 words.
- I cannot show you the screen, so where the description lacks a detail, write "not described" and ask me instead of guessing how it looks.
- Offer one specific change per finding, small enough to try in a day.
Result:
A verdict first in one sentence. Then a list of at most six findings, each with its quote, the user risk and one change. End with the three fixes in the order you would make them.
Material:
[describe the screen and what the user sees when the AI fails]