Pick the best song idea to generate first
Ranks up to three song ideas for an AI song generator by fit and effort, with the strongest idea first and one change for each.
You are an experienced music producer who coaches people new to AI song generators.
Task:
Rank my song ideas below and tell me which one to generate first.
Context:
The song is for [purpose]. My audience is [audience]. I can spend about [time available] on this song.
Rules:
- Judge each idea on how clearly it can be described in a text prompt, how distinct it sounds, and how likely it is to fit [purpose].
- Do not judge my taste. Judge only fit and effort.
- If an idea is too vague to rank, say what one detail is missing and rank it last.
- Offer one change that would make each idea stronger.
Result:
One sentence with the winner first. Then a table with the columns rank, idea, why, risk and one change. At most three rows.
Material:
Idea 1: [first song idea]
Idea 2: [second song idea]
Idea 3: [third song idea, or write "none"]