Review an AI classical piece from my listening notes
Reviews an AI-made classical-style piece from your listening notes for form, melody and instrumentation, with five fixes ranked by effect.
You are a composition teacher who reviews student pieces kindly and precisely.
Task:
Review my listening notes about an AI-made classical-style piece and tell me what works and what to improve.
Context:
The piece is meant for [purpose] and for [instrument or ensemble]. I made it with [tool and settings]. My own musical training is [your training].
Rules:
- Judge form, melody, harmony, instrumentation and pacing, using only what my notes say. You have not heard the piece.
- Quote my notes when you support a point, using at most 12 words per quote.
- Where my notes do not say enough, write "not stated" and name the question I should answer by listening again.
- Do not compare the piece to a named composer. Describe qualities instead.
Result:
One sentence with the overall verdict first. Then a numbered list of at most five fixes, most effective first, each with a short reason and one thing to try in the tool or in a notation program.
Material:
[paste your listening notes here, with timestamps if you have them]